|
| |
|
Bubble Wand Question 2/23/08
Helloa again Bob (and crew members)....
<Hi Lisa, do not think Bob is in Helloa land now, but may still be wearing his
lei.>
I've had my 10 gal Q-tank set up for 3 days now (50% existing tank water/50%
fresh saltwater), heater running, filter has been in my 125 gal FOWLR sump for a
week, and the pvc pipe piece is in and ready to provide shelter for my new fish.
My question is....previously when I had the Q-tank set up, I used an older
bubble wand that someone gave me. That has since broken so I bought a new one
yesterday. This little wand is cranking out some air bubbles.....the entire 10
gallons is filled with moving bubbles. Is this way too much oxygen in the water?
<Air stones do not really put oxygen in the water, they merely bring the water
to the surface where it can exchange gas with air.>
Will this stress a new fish out to the max? Everything else (water parameters)
is fine....bare bottom etc. BUT, I'm a bit concerned about the amount of air
being pumped into the tank.......is it needed (or can you suggest a better way).
I've been searching throughout the archives and just can't find the answers I'm
looking for.
<Lisa, just go with a small powerhead and place near the surface, is all you
need. Problem with air stones, wands, is that they create salt creep and make a
mess along with the noisy air pump.>
Thank you all again for taking time out of your busy days to help and educate
all the other wet pet fanatics out here.
<Thank you, and you're welcome. James (Salty Dog)>
Lisa
Re: Bubble Wand
Question 2/24/08
Helloa again Bob (and crew members)....
<Hi Lisa, do not think Bob is in Helloa land now, but may still be
wearing his lei.>
LOL...good one James!??? And yes, I deserved that one.? :o)
Thank you for the advice with the bubble wand....I removed it and have a
powerhead in the Q-Tank now.
<Much better and no salt mess.>
Since you did such a fantastic job helping with my last question (yes, I
am trying to butter you up for more advice if you couldn't tell....lol);
I was hoping to ask more on your DSB thoughts. l have a 125 gal FOWLR
with a DSB.....40 gal sump/refugium with LR and DSB w/Chaeto and a
"decent" protein skimmer. Over time and initial powerhead mis-placement,
sand has moved and I think even diminished some and I'd like to add more
sand. The "deepest" area is 6" but I'd like to try and get the majority
up to at least 6" overall. I do not plan on removing any rock
though......would it be possible to just add new sand on top of the
existing sand to level it all over? Initially I used Home Depot Play
sand and seeded it with live sand.
<Have to be careful here with "play sand", some play sand is pure silica
sand, something we do not want in our reef systems.>
"Dead" rock was used as a base with LR from a 6yr old established reef
tank was used to seed the base rock. I had in the past used crabs and
sand sifting stars but removed them when I bought my Looney (oops, I
meant Lunare? lol) Wrasse. I now have an ugly line of algae ( and on the
surface layer) and such and would like to clean it up a bit. What would
you recommend critter wise to do this? And should I have the sand
"cleaned" before adding the new sand?
<With the Lunare Wrasse present, I do not know of any algae cleaning
critter that would be safe with it. I'd use a gravel cleaner during
water changes to clean your sand bed.
It takes a little getting used to as to how much to pinch the hose to
prevent sucking the sand out of the tank. Is the method I use and it
doesn't take too long to master.
Is one reason I do not care for the larger wrasses, all those colorful
inverts cannot be kept.>
Thank you again Mr. Salty Dog....look forward to hearing from you again.
<You're welcome. James (Salty Dog)>
Attached is a photo of the tank after it cycled (about 3 months after
initial set up)
Another recent photo of the tank
And I had to add one of my favorite fish, Looney, the Lunare wrasse. Who
btw must be a male as the colors have deepened A LOT over the last year.
The lyre tail has grown so much as well and this fish has the nicest
personality. The "troublemaker" in the bunch is my Coral Beauty. The
wrasse is your typical active crazy pig of a fish but has not shown any
real "aggression" since it was added to the tank. Maybe I'm
lucky....maybe my time will come!? lol???
<They all have different personalities but read from the same menu.>
I think because I keep him well fed with a large variety of food and he
has lots of nooks and crannies to swim through and keep busy that he
doesn't have time to worry about defending his meals or territory.
<Does help reduce aggression.>
Just thought I'd share (sorry...I am a typical "diarrhea of the mouth"
female.) Don't even get me started about my horses, dogs, cats,
parrots.....oh yeah, and my 17yr daughter!? lol
<I won't touch that. I do not see any pics or attachments, just text
reading "View full size".>
Lisa |
Bubbles... SW aeration... shark hatch-out size
Hi Should all marine tanks have bubbles?
<Mmm, no... as in floating around... but circulation, aeration... yes>
My LFS said no!! An air pump,
<Mmm, can be provided in other ways>
also how big does the black banned cat shark hatch at?
<A few inches... see fishbase.org re...>
Please let me know if I should get some bubbles<(..)>
Thanks
<Please read here:
http://wetwebmedia.com/aerationmarart.htm
and the linked files above. BobF>
Small Air Pump Recommendations 11/30/06
Hello Bob,
<Hey Greg, JustinN with you this morning.>
I've recently determined that my tank has too much CO2. I to
want to add a small air pump with air stone.
<Ok>
My question is of course, have you had much experience with air pumps? My tank
is six gallons. I'd like to get a high, maybe highest quality one available. I'm
shooting for ease of maintenance and silence. Silence is my number one priority
because the tank is in my bedroom. So any brands that you might mention would
be greatly appreciated!
<Well, the nice thing about diaphragm air pumps is how simply they are
constructed... likely any standard small aquarium air pump will serve your
purpose fine. I've had good luck with Tetra air pumps in the past.>
Also wanted to say thanks for your invaluable service to hobbyists like me.
Haven't found a better quality web site! Greg
<Thanks for the kind words, Greg! Take care! -JustinN>
Air pump Sel. 11/29/06
Hello,
<Hey Greg, JustinN with you tonight>
I'm wondering what is the quietest, highest quality air pump on the
market to be used for aerating a six gallon saltwater tank. Thanks, Greg
<Just about any commercially available air pump should do the job, but Tetra
makes a quality pump for a specific brand. Hope this helps you! -JustinN>
Luft Pump is not 7 PSI! 11/15/06
Hi Bob,
<Loren>
I run two ozone generators that use a proprietary air pump, which is specified
at 2.8 LPM (0.1 CFM) at 4.0 PSI, and 6.0 PSI dead head. The pumps fail
regularly, repair parts are not available, and they cost over $150 to replace,
<Mmmm... too high... In the States this unit sells for $40-45...>
so I've been looking for a better solution.
<I see>
The Coralife Luft Pump claims "7.0 PSI" and "4.0 LPM", which sounds like it
might work.
<Mmm, this is the same/identical pump as the Tetra Luft pump... both companies
owned by a large conglomerate nowadays... Used to be made/assembled in
Deutschland... "Luft"... Has been assembled in the U.S. (Blacksburg, VA) for the
last decade or so. Seen this in person>
Mostly on the rave recommendation of your "air_pump_impressions" page:
<http://www.wetwebmedia.com/ca/volume_2/cav2i6/impressions/air_pump_impressions.htm>
I ordered one. The pump I received seems to be working normally, and puts out
more air than my existing pump at low head, but at its
maximum setting it will only reach 3.5 PSI on my test gauge. I actually verified
its displacement in a tank, where it only reaches
97.5 inches, which works out to 3.52 PSI.
<Mmm...>
So... Is the "7.0 PSI" that is written all over the box grossly exaggerated, or
is there some unique convention I've never heard of
for measuring aquarium pumps, or could I have received a substandard unit?
<Don't know re either... PSI is PSI... at whatever volume... to static
pressure... I suspect there is (likely) some variance, but not much unit to
unit... I would be writing Coralife/Tetra re...>
I notice that it does not hold any pressure against the gauge after I unplug it
- the needle drops to zero within about one second.
<Mmm...>
I can actually blow air backward through it while it is off, which makes me
think the valves must not be sealing very well.
<I agree... there should be two "flapper" one-way valves that retain pressure,
resist your blowing back... I would install a check valve in line here for sure
either way>
I contacted "Rob Moneyhan"
<rmoneyhan@central-aquatics.com> at the vendor's support site, and here is
his response:
-----
The Luft pump was purchased from Tetra Corporation, and when our company
acquired
it there was no testing done on it. The same pressure ratings were used by
marketing. If you were to put a hose coming from the pump down into water 16 or
so inches and tested the force that the air was putting out against the force of
the water it may register near 7PSI.
<?..... no... Too lazy to do the math here, but discounting induced and other
drag, there is no such predictability at 16 inches... Put another way, the 7 PSI
should be produced whether a line is submerged or not...>
This particular pump is a diaphragm pump and has areas were air pressure can
escape.
-----
Obviously he doesn't understand the science involved, but essentially, after
having his techs do tests in their "lab", he seems
to be saying the Luft Pump really doesn't do 7.0 PSI like everybody claims it
should.
You might want to warn people...
So... Any ideas about a somewhat quiet, low power consumption air pump that
would actually do about 0.1 CFM at a 96" depth? Rena 400?
Tetra DW96-2?
Loren
<Am still a fan of the Luft pump... I do believe you may have gotten a bunk
one... and would really like a larger sample size before condemning the model
out of hand. Am hoping others will chime in here and render their experiences.
Cheers, Bob Fenner>
Re: Luft Pump is not 7 PSI! – 11/15/06
Bob,
<Loren>
At 06:36 PM 11/14/2006, you wrote:
><Am still a fan of the Luft pump... I do believe you may have gotten a bunk
one... and would really like a larger sample size before condemning the model
out of hand. Am hoping others will chime in here and render their experiences.
Cheers, Bob Fenner>
I'd really like to believe I just got a bad one. (And that Coralife or
Central-Aquatics or Energy Savers or whoever's tech people don't understand
basic physics.) If it could provide decent air volume at 96" depth it would be
perfect for my use. Has anybody with a deep tank ever seen one work at 96"
depth?
<Mmm, have used and sold many dozens of this make/model in years past... for
even outdoor use (in/with ponds)... for operating sponge filters, long/large
glass "airstones"... Our faves, the ones from Aquatic EcoSystem>
Maybe I will just peek inside and see if there is an obvious problem...
Loren
<Worthwhile... there is one central diaphragm... it's a bit hard to dismantle...
Again, maybe taking your pressure gauge to a large LFS and testing on site the
units they have on hand? Bob Fenner>
Electro magnetic air pump/ Sharks 8/31/06
Hi Bob,
<Joe>
Was hoping you could shed some light on the myth that sharks are sensitive to
electro magnetic fields?
<Mmm, not a myth. Established fact>
I am thinking of purchasing a new air pump for my tank, although it is described
as operating via an electro-magnetic motor. I have a port Jackson shark in my
tank, and was wondering if this would affect him, or any shark in general.
<Not likely... through the air... or even if this pump is placed near the tank>
Also, could you please tell me what a sufficient air output in an 8ft tank
should be (if there is a suggested air volume at all)? The air pump I have
selected distributes 70 litres per minute.
<... At what pressure? Depends on the depth, number of discharges... what
mechanical diffuser devices, other outputs are employed. 70 LPM is a bunch of
volume>
Thanks
Joe.
<Bob Fenner>
Air pump choices, Printed works on Aquariology 02-05-06
Dear Fenner,
<Stephan>
As i
<... I>
consider myself more immersed within the intricacies of the hobby i would like
to ask you a few questions, if that's alright. I'm considering
building a fish room and would like to know the appropriate air pump for the
job. I've done some searching around and found 3 types available to the
everyday consumers. Larger regular pumps, air compressors and blowers
(diaphragms etc). What i wanted to know was whether high pressure low volume
or high volume low pressure air was more desirable for the longevity of the
fish.
<Blowers are by far the most appropriate technology for such fish rooms... you
don't (likely) need high/er pressure... or the noise that goes with such...>
As they seem to be the only discrepancy between the available models.
Furthermore, i would like to ask if there were more sources that i can view
to learn more about the biology of tropical fish. Being a science major myself,
i feel that the science behind living fish is pertinent to my needs.
Thank you for your time,
Sincerely,
Stephen Fang
<The last is a very good question. Presently there are few "scientific" works on
Aquariology... so a person is faced with sampling from related fields
(Aquaculture, Ichthyology, Physiology...) and making inference... Perhaps you
will pen such a work. Bob Fenner>
Noisy Air Pump 12/15/05
We have a "Elite 802" air stone
< Actually the Elite 802 is a pump, not an airstone.>
for a 10 gallon tank that is really noisy. Do you have any recommendations for
any air stone's <pumps> that aren't noisy? This thing is pretty loud and we even
have it laying on a folded over dishtowel to buffer some of the noise. Thank
you!
< This is a very common problem that aquarists encounter with small aquariums.
Little vibrating air pumps are relatively inexpensive but almost all of them
work off a vibrating diaphragm. With little plastic housings there is not enough
ballast around them to contain the vibration or the noise. Bigger ones were
sometimes no better. The was a company many years ago that made an outstanding
pump called the Silent Giant. It was an incredibly powerful pump that you could
hardly hear. Unfortunately they began to use cheaper materials, the quality went
down and they were not nearly as good and the company went out of business.
Unplug the air pump from the airline while it is till plugged in. This is as
quiet as it is ever going to get. Lots of the vibration comes from excessive
back pressure, liked clogged airstones or kinked airlines. If the problems are
fixed but it is still too noisy then you will have to change to an outside power
filter. Other little air pumps are not going to be much better. Look at the
penguin brands. The only noise you will hear is the sound of water running over
the filter. Some people actually find it relaxing.-Chuck>
Air pump
Hey folks!
Just started a 20g saltwater tank and got a, (shudder) Skilter 250.
Yea, I know, say it ain't so. Anyway, I found the Skilter modification
in the FAQ and have completed it with the help of the LFS that I like
here. Main reason for doing it was it seems to inject a ton of bubbles
back into the tank. Much better now. I have an ashwood air stone
running off of a Tectra Deep water 24-2. I was wondering if it would be appropriate to simply plug the
non-used outlet of the pump for the time
being (and to save my sanity from the noise) with a piece of tube with
a plug on the end of it. I was thinking that when I setup an additional tank for QT, I would run hose from the other outlet to it
for air, etc. Will this burn out my pump or be ok? Love your site, very
very informational! <Dan, I would use a "T" and use both lines, if it's too much air you can always add an inline flow control.> James (Salty Dog)>
Rebuild Kits for Whisper Air Pumps
I have two Whisper air pumps, one is a 700, the other is a 600....I cannot
find the rebuild kits in my local shops anymore! Where can I get them besides on
the Web? I live in Saint Joseph Michigan.
Thank you
Donna
<Most any of the larger LFS or etailers that carry much in the way of Tetra's
product lines should be able to get this for you. Check with Custom Aquatic,
Marine Depot (.coms). Bob Fenner>
Battery Operated pumps
Thanks for the reply. Any idea how long battery operated pumps
last? I had always thought them to last just a few hours at
best.
<you are right, they aren't very long. I'm sorry, I forgot to
mention that if you are going to get a battery operated one, then also invest in
a decent rechargeable battery system. "Monster Power"
battery systems work exceedingly well, and have a long power life. You can find
it at Circuit city and a reasonable price. have the batteries charging as the
other ones are in use. You don't have the have the pump running all the time
either. Just have it going during the warmest part of the day, and sporadically
during other times. It's not really needed directly after a large
water change, so keep that in mind. Actually I'm not sure why I
didn't think of this last time, but you don't need to have a pump near the
tank. You can always purchase airline hosing and run a single line of
airline to the tank. The pump can be near an outlet, and just the
airline goes to the tank. You can purchase a 25foot roll of it for about 10
dollars at Petco.>
Thanks again, Mark
<Hope that helps, I would suggest using the long airline tubing rather than
the cost of a noisy battery pump, and battery charging expense. Good
luck. -Magnus>
-Rely on battery powered air pumps?-
I was trying to get your opinion as whether or not these battery powered air
pumps would be enough to sustain a 75 gallon reef tank for a couple of days if
their was a power failure(24 hours +). <It's hard to say, and it depends on
how the tank is set up. Assuming the temperature could stay constant, and the
tank had ample live rock and a reasonable population of fish and critters, a few
air pumps keeping the water from going stagnant may do the trick.> I am in a
climate where for the most part, I would not have to worry about the temperature
past 48 hours. Hagen makes a battery powered air pump for like seven dollars. Do
you have any other recommendation in case of a prolonged power failure?
<Yeah, generator. An excellent investment not only for the tank but for your
own personal comfort! -Kevin> Please let me know. Thanks Ron
Air Pump Noise
Hey Crew!!
Ok, here's my problem - I have an air pump that's driving me nuts!! I
would like to know if you guys could tell me what the quietest air pump on the
market is. I'm running a protein skimmer, and 2 air stones in
the tank. Would 2 really quiet pumps take care of my needs, and
quiet things down?? Thanks for your advise!! Pat Marren
<Try asking in the WetWebFoto forums, Pat. The problem with air pumps for
driving skimmer air stones is, they need to be powerful enough to push air quite
deep, thus the noise. I'm afraid it's fairly typical. Someone may
know of a particularly quiet model on the forums. Craig>
Pump It Up?
I have a bio orb and have just changed the filter cartridge on Monday!
However have not been able to get it to bubble up since!
<Hmm...>
Have taken pump to my local aquarium 3 times and have had it fixed and checked
all seems ok to them! It even blew bubbles into a cup, yet whenever I get it
home it just doesn't want to work! Can you think of any other reason for this
before I go mad!!!!
Caroline Cutmore
<OK, Caroline- here's my theory: Perhaps there is too much back pressure on
the pump in your setup? If the pump is more than say, one meter below the tank,
perhaps it cannot overcome the back pressure. Experiment by moving the pump
closer to the filter, perhaps even on top of the tank...See if that works for
you. It may be as simple as that. If this is the case, you may need to either
permanently relocate the pump to a more favorable position, or purchase a more
powerful one. Hope this helps! Regards, Scott F!>
Re: two pumps & PSI
UPDATE:
Bob,
I received a new air pump for Christmas.. a 4 PSI one. I'll I can say is WOW,
what a difference 2 more PSI make in a skimmer.
<Yes sir!>
With my 2" 5' DIY CC Skimmer and a 2 PSI pump I could barely get foam to
the top, and the air stone was only 12" down. With a 4 PSI air pump, and
stone 18" down I have foam gushing over the top. I actually had to dial the
air pump down to 3 PSI to get the foam at proper levels.
I hope this might help others with foam issues. Thanks again for all your help.
Dave
<Thanks for the input. Bob Fenner>
Re: two pumps & PSI
Good Morning to the "All knowing and All seeing keepers of knowledge in all
things aquatic". I come before you on bent knee, again seeking counsel and
pearls of wisdom.
<Wow!>
If you have two air pumps that are churning out 2 PSI each, when you hook them
together (into the same gang valve) would you not get 4 PSI as a result? When I
did this and only saw a 0.5 raise in total PSI. Went from 2 to 2.5
Puzzled, Dave
<Well Dave, the answer is simple. My Dad has a saying, "You can't fit
ten pounds of sh*! in a five pound bag." Basically, the airline tubing is
only able to accomodate so much air. Much like using a 1200 gph external pump
and only getting 400 gph out of it because you are returning the water through
1/2" PVC pipe. -Steven Pro>
Re: Air Pump Question for tall skimmer
I would like to use 1/4" ID acrylic and flexible tubing to supply air into
my 5' skimmer.
<yes... but you will not need for the air to go much further than 16 or
18" down a countercurrent body>
If I have a 5' skimmer shouldn't the air go all the way to the bottom or very
near it?
<nope... not necessary at all in a Nilsen style countercurrent. Too expensive
to produce and actually a problem when you have adequate water flow through the
skimmer: air near the bottom can get sucked out with the excurrent water and be
aesthetically irritating to you and especially irritating to corals (the
microbubbles).>
Or am I misunderstanding what you are saying?
<You understand my friend... just don't have a good diagram or understanding
of it yet. It would be obvious after you built the skimmer. This skimmer style
is diagramed in my coral propagation book... an old Nilsen style at 4-6 feet
tall. Great old design. Best regards, Anthony>
Air Pump Question
A question for the experts at WWM. Great site, great people! Can two, three or
four Tetra Luft air pumps be tied into a common header to operate a single CC
skimmer?
<yes... but never with significant back pressure... always with a bleeder
(blowing off air and throttled just enough to give the other outlets the
necessary flow. To illustrate... imagine a gang valve with four outlets and two
inlets. Two pumps (single output) would supply the two inlets... three of the
outlets would go to a device (airstone) and the fourth must be left to blow off
air. The three outlets will need to be run at the same depth and their valves
left full open. Only the bleeder is regulated (throttled back) to get enough
flow to other outlets>
Or would separate lines for each be necessary?
<always better and safer separately>
Would each require a check valve?
<yes>
I would like to use 1/4" ID acrylic and flexible tubing to supply air into
my 5' skimmer.
<yes... but you will not need for the air to go much further than 16 or
18" down a countercurrent body>
Would this combination shorten the life of the pumps?
<the first suggestion would a little. There are industrial airpumps instead
that are suited for this job (Schego)>
Do you have a better setup? Any help would be very much appreciated.
<best regards, Anthony>
Schego air pump
Dear crew,
I have just purchased a Schego M2K3 air pump from seeme.com in the Netherlands,
what a fantastic piece of kit very well made compared with the majority of what
we normally see over here in England.
<and here in America too. Schego has enjoyed a fine reputation for many
years. Its a shame that they are so dearly priced>
My question is this, at the moment i am using Sander No2 limewood stones, the
action in the skimmer column is very high but it's reluctant to start foaming, i
have an internal glass counter current skimmer and the depth is about 18"
of the column, i currently only use 1 airstone (should i start using 2 stones),
<dual airstones is not a terrible idea if you cannot increase air through the
stone without increasing bubble size>
can you guys give any pointers as to any experience with these pumps, by the way
i have it set fairly light in terms of the tension dial on the end of the pump.
<as will all high volume air pumps... hook this one up to a gang valve with
one more stem than you need (e.g.- two valves for one running stone or three
valves for two running stones). Set the airstone valve(s) full open and use the
extra valve as a bleeder/muffler. Attach a length of tubing to it and restrict
or open the valve slightly to make adjustments by resistance for the airstones.
This maximizes control of airflow and reduces resistance on the pump.
Many thanks Paul, England
<Cheers, Paul. With kind regards... Anthony Calfo>
Schego Air Pumps
Dear Anthony,
<cheers, Paul>
Thank you for your reply with regard to my air pump problem, i will go to my
local aquarium shop tomorrow and buy a gang valve and give it a go!
<excellent!>
By the way the site that I bought the pump of does the M2K3 for $31.00 and if
you spend in excess of $75.00 they will deliver free to the good old US of A.
<that is very affordable for such a good pump! Please do share the web link
with us>
Once again thanks for the advice, it's much appreciated,
<our great pleasure>
I haven't been able to get a satisfactory answer over here in England simply
because no-one sells Schego pumps at all.
<I see... well, I suppose you just need to think a little more about retiring
early and setting up that fine aquarium Shoppe you've been dreaming about!
<G> Do advise me when your grand opening is... I'd love to visit UK on
holiday and lecture at your new place (Ha!)... and I'll travel for
good beer, steamed rice and a comfortable chair to sleep in :) >
Yours Paul, Manchester, England
<kindly, Anthony>
Air Pumps for Skimmers
Dear Mr Fenner,
<Steven Pro in this evening.>
Thank you for your reply regarding the reef secure additive. If you do get any
information on this product I would be grateful for your views. A couple of
weeks ago, I mailed you with regard to some Kordon mist fine air stones that I
purchased on the web. I am trying to increase the efficiency of my air driven
counter current skimmer. You kindly pointed me in the direction of Schego or
Luft air pumps. I have managed to locate the Schego pumps on the web, but after
reading some viewpoints it seems that a lot of people in America think that they
can be quite noisy. I have been looking around and I have seen another pump
called the TetraTec deep water. Apparently, its been developed for skimmer
operation. Could you please let me know if any of the crew or you has ever come
across this and what your views are?
<I have seen them, but I am partial to the Tetra Luft pumps, now marketed
under the Coralife label, but they should be the same. These are strong, long
lasting, and have an adjustable rheostat.>
As always thank you for your efforts, Paul Matthews of Manchester, England
<You are welcome. -Steven Pro>
| |
|